Detailed evaluation

Please answer the following questions.

Note: For each question, please indicate a 1 to 5 score
(1=Unacceptable ; 2=Poor; 3=Sufficient; 4=Good; 5=Excellent)

1. Is this PhD thesis written in correct scientific language and style? *

2. Does the introduction present a critical and up-to-date literature review relevant to the topic of the PhD project? *

3. Are the motivations, objectives, and methodological approaches of the research clearly stated and described? *

4. Are results presented in adequate detail (e.g. figure quality, graphics, figure legends), and with an appropriate logical flow and discussion? *

5. Are limitations to the theoretical and/or experimental approaches and/or results obtained recognized and critically discussed? *

6. Has the industrial impact of the work been satisfactorily addressed? *

7. Are the conclusions well supported and coherent with respect to the developed research activities? *

8. Does this PhD thesis represent an original and valuable contribute to the field? *

9. How would you rate this thesis in overall? *

Please, write your review report, highlighting the main and original results, positive and/or negative aspects of the thesis, etc.

Cancel

Altro