Detailed evaluation

Please answer the following questions

Note: For each question, please indicate a 1 to 5 score
(1=Unacceptable ; 2=Poor; 3= Sufficient; 4= Good; 5= Excellent)

Does the introduction present a critical and up-to-date literature review relevant to the topic of the PhD project? *

Comment (optional)

Are the motivations and objectives of the research clearly stated? *

Comment (optional)

Are the methodological approaches appropriately and adequately described for the planned objectives? *

Comment (optional)

How would you rate the original contribution of the PhD candidate in the methodology (if applicable)?

Comment (optional)

Is data analyses conducted with sufficient depth and appropriate methodologies (if applicable)?

Comment (optional)

Are results presented in adequate detail (e.g. figure quality, graphics, figure legends) and with an appropriate logical flow? *

No label

Do the obtained results justify the conclusions? *

Comment (optional)

Are limitations to the theoretical and/or experimental approaches and/or results obtained recognized and critically discussed? *

Comment (optional)

Are the findings appropriately discussed in the context of the current literature? *

Comment (optional)

Cancel

Altro